After 12 years in Canada, ex-spy faces deportation

VANCOUVER, B.C. – For the past 12 years, Mikhail and Irina Lennikov have lived unremarkable lives, not unlike other immigrants who came to Canada from Eastern Europe looking for a fresh start in a prosperous and quiet land.

He found a job as a software developer. She got hired in an insurance office. Their son, Dmitri, who barely remembers Russia, graduated in June from Byrne Creek Secondary School in the comfortable suburb of Burnaby.

But Mikhail Lennikov’s employer years ago in the former Union of Soviet Socialist Republics was the KGB, the USSR’s chief national security and espionage agency.

Citing a law that denies permanent residency to employees of agencies that engage in espionage or subversion against democratic governments, a Canadian judge in June ordered Lennikov deported to Russia.

The legal decision has touched a nerve in British Columbia, where the former KGB agent’s friends and neighbors, along with thousands of other Canadian citizens and 23 members of Parliament, have rallied to his defense – holding marches, parades and petition drives.

So has his church, which has given the soft-spoken, graying Lennikov, an Asian studies expert, sanctuary within its walls in defiance of the government’s attempts to put him on a plane back to Vladivostok, his hometown in Russia’s far east.

“From our perspective, he’s one of us. He’s part of this congregation. And when we said we were going to support him, we didn’t just mean with e-mails and phone calls and faxes. We weren’t going to let this happen without doing everything we can,” said Richard Hergesheimer, pastor at First Lutheran Church, where Lennikov has taken refuge since June 2.

Unlike law-enforcement authorities in the United States, Canadian officials have honored churches’ exercise of the ages-old tradition of sanctuary to those fleeing what religious leaders see as unjust laws.

But the Canadian Border Services Agency has refused to rule out apprehending Lennikov, prompting everyone at the church – from its music leader to its Sunday school teachers – to adopt an anxious regimen of heightened security. Doors are locked; visitors who ring the bell are quizzed before being admitted.

“We have not entered into a church to arrest someone in the past, but there is no law preventing us from doing so,” said Faith St. John, spokeswoman for the Canadian border agency.

No one has suggested that Lennikov, 48, engaged in acts of violence or intimidation when he held the rank of captain in the KGB for six years in the 1980s. Lennikov has said he was not given much choice when recruited to work for the agency after his graduation in Japanese studies from the Far Eastern National University in Vladivostok, and he left the KGB as soon as he could.

Fluent in Japanese, Lennikov spent his years with the KGB monitoring Japanese businesses and translating documents. He said he never felt comfortable with what he saw as the organization’s anti-democratic culture.

“Many of them didn’t value other people’s lives,” Lennikov said of his former colleagues. “They were obsessed just with their advances in career and, you know, the whole morality of the organization, believing that they’re kind of gods, deciding other people’s lives.”

“For myself, I was swept away by (Soviet leader Mikhail) Gorbachev’s new policy, openness and honesty, and just was not careful enough in expressing my views at one of the officers’ meetings, and it turned out to be that I angered some people. I just sensed it, that something bad was going on behind my back,” he said.

His KGB friends let him know that his resignation in 1988 was seen as the act of a traitor. As soon as he could, Lennikov left Russia, first to work in Japan and then in 1997 to enter graduate school at the University of British Columbia, Vancouver.

His wife and son moved to Canada with him. Lennikov did not reveal his employment history on his student visa application, but listed “Committee for State Security” on his permanent residency application in 1999. Canadian authorities appeared not to notice its significance until a personal interview in March 2000, when he explained that the agency was known in the West as the KGB.

That triggered an automatic denial of his residency application.

Lennikov appealed, arguing that – as a result of his meetings with Canadian security services, during which he gave them full details about his employment with the KGB – he could be arrested for treason should he return to Russia.

In a final ruling June 1 from which no further appeal except a humanitarian exemption is possible, Federal Court Judge Russel W. Zinn cited the findings of an assessment officer who acknowledged that other former agents who left the KGB and successor agencies had faced reprisals, including arrest.

The officer mentioned the case of Alexander Litvinenko, the former agent who was poisoned with radioactive polonium in London in 2006 after accusing Russian security services of complicity in apartment bombings ostensibly linked to the war in Chechnya. Russian authorities have been accused of involvement in the poisoning, which they deny.

But Lennikov’s case was not of a similar magnitude, the officer found, stating that the former KGB officer did “not indicate having worked with technical or other scientific information which may be considered sensitive by the Russian authorities.”

Officials were also unswayed by Lennikov’s claims that, at various times while in Vancouver, he had run into three men he knew to be Russian security agents, one of whom appeared to be monitoring him.

Oleg Gordievsky, a former KGB colonel who defected to Britain in 1985 and wrote one of the definitive histories of the agency, said agents seen as defectors are dealt with harshly.

“To say that the Russian-Soviet authorities do not bother about the defectors is absurd. … They … have a special KGB department monitoring the whereabouts and movements of all KGB and GRU defectors,” he said in an e-mail message.

The GRU is Russia’s largest foreign intelligence agency.

At minimum, Lennikov faces the possibility of permanent separation from his wife and son. Irina and Dmitri have been granted permission to apply for permanent residency in Canada, and probably will do so to avoid the risk of Dmitri being drafted into the Russian army.

Lennikov lives in a small room at the church and spends his days taking phone calls and replying to e-mails. Irina, who now must find a second job, visits about three times a week. Church members stop by with a hot dish for dinner and a brief chat.

“My main question is why it’s happening,” Lennikov said. “Why am I such a threat?”